Mudslide

The Mudslide—a combination of vodka, coffee liqueur, Irish cream, and heavy cream—is the quintessential boozy milkshake. Sweet, creamy, and rich, its popularity harkens back to a time when we took our cocktail cues from the laminated menus of chain restaurants. Which is to say, the Mudslide is not exactly an exercise in balance and craftsmanship. But it sure is an enjoyable concoction.

The Mudslide was born in the 1970s at Wreck Bar in Rum Point Club on Grand Cayman Island. Yes, it seems more like an après-ski cocktail than something you’d sip on a sandy beach. But it was invented when a customer wanted a White Russian and the bar tweaked the recipe to feature Irish cream. The effortless drink was a hit, finding its way to the shores of the United States and quickly became a favorite at TGI Friday’s and at home cocktail parties.

Why the Mudslide Works

Most versions of the Mudslide are drowned in ice cream and served in circus-size glassware, resulting in a brain freeze and your daily dose of calories in one cocktail. There’s a place for such extremity. But the recipe for this Mudslide sways leaner and showcases the spirits rather than only the sugar and dairy.

The creamy element is two-fold: Baileys Irish Cream and heavy cream. With all that richness, the drink needs some edge to cut through the dairy assault. In comes the vodka and coffee liqueur, the former slicing through the intensity and the latter complementing the richness while also adding coffee’s singular acerbity. A Mudslide needs “mud” and that is where the chocolate garnish steps in to add a visual hint of “mud,” while also lending additional aroma and flavor.

Make a Mudslide after dinner or whenever you have a sweet tooth. Using heavy cream is the best bet here, as 2% milk or skim are too lean to produce the richness a Mudslide requires. If you really want to fancify your drink, swap the vodka for your favorite French brandy. Unconventional, for sure. But the brandy’s aged roundness provides its own special kind of complement to the Mudslide.

Ingredients

• 1 ounce vodka
• 1 ounce coffee liqueur
• 1 ounce Baileys Irish cream
• 1 1/2 ounces heavy cream
• Garnish: chocolate shavings

Steps

1. Add the vodka, coffee liqueur, Baileys and cream to a shaker with ice and shake until well-chilled.
2. Strain into a chilled fizz glass or coupe.
3. Garnish with freshly shaved chocolate.