We Tested 13 Grocery Store Coffees and Here's the Best One

Updated Apr 17, 2026 · 2 min read

I keep a Mr. Coffee automatic drip coffee maker, two French presses, a travel mug-French press combo, a Mr. Coffee espresso machine I purchased in college, a black plastic pour-ove.

Your thorough coffee tasting analysis is entertaining and relatable! Your methodical approach is evident, which is essential for any true coffee lover. Here’s a streamlined summary of your findings, highlighting the key contenders and insights:

Best Grocery Store CoffeesTop Choice: Maxwell House Original

• Price: $5.83/lb
• Flavor: Solid and uncomplicated, ideal for daily consumption.
• It is not advised to microwave; the flavor is greatly diminished when reheated.
• As it cools, thermal shift may cause it to turn bitter.

Runner-Up: New England Coffee Breakfast Blend

• Price: $9.99/lb
• Flavor: Smooth and enjoyable; reheats well.
• Thermal Shift: Retains drinkability as it cools.

Best Value Overall: Eight O'Clock Coffee Original

• Price: $11.19/lb (around $7.69 for a 12-ounce bag)
• Flavor: Dark without bitterness; surprisingly good for the price.
• Microwaveability: Performs well when reheated.

Noteworthy Contenders:

• Green Mountain Breakfast Blend
• Price: $13.32/lb
• Flavor: Light and pleasant; excellent thermal performance.
• Café Bustelo
• Price: $6.38/lb
• Flavor: Robust; best for those who enjoy a strong brew. Not microwave-friendly.
• Dunkin' Donuts Original Blend
• Price: $12.39/lb
• Flavor: Smooth and drinkable; closer to café experience at home.

Avoid: Starbucks House Blend

• Price: $13.59/lb
• Flavor: Often described as stale; not recommended for home brewing.

Key Takeaways:

1. Cost-Effectiveness: Companies like Eight of the Clock and Maxwell House offer excellent value without sacrificing flavor.
2. Microwave Performance: Most coffees are best enjoyed fresh; Maxwell House and Café Bustelo are not the best options if reheating is required.
3. Taste Testing Method: Using a ceramic pour-over guarantees reliable results while emphasizing the experience of pure coffee.

With this guide, fellow coffee lovers can shop with confidence and satisfy their daily craving without going over budget! Cheers to finding the perfect brew!

4o mini